Florida investigators say a construction company owner paid $9,297.43 for a year of workers compensation coverage while more than $968,000 in payroll went unreported. The premium loss they calculated is $100,565.57. That figure matters because it sits $565.57 over a line that changes the felony degree.
If you are studying for the Florida Business and Finance exam, this case tests the workers compensation fraud ladder in Section 440.105. The exam expects you to know which dollar band controls, and to keep the workers comp ladder separate from the grand theft and organized fraud ladders, which use different numbers.
This is an independent study aid, not affiliated with the DBPR, the Construction Industry Licensing Board, or Pearson VUE. It is a study summary, not legal advice. An arrest is an allegation; Carballo is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
01What happened
Per the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS) press release dated November 10, 2026, announced by Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia, with the release's figures summarized in secondary reporting of the announcement the same day:
- Israel Carballo, identified by DFS as a construction company owner, was arrested on November 5, 2026 by the DFS Criminal Investigations Division (CID).
- Investigators allege Carballo fraudulently underreported payroll amounts to his insurance company to avoid paying a higher workers compensation premium.
- Investigators put unreported payroll at $968,278.71, and say $1,074,278.71 in checks were cashed through money service businesses to conceal payroll from the insurer.
- Carballo paid $9,297.43 for the policy year. Investigators calculated $100,565.57 in lost premiums. The two premium figures sum to $109,863.00.
- DFS says Carballo faces charges of grand theft, organized scheme to defraud, and workers compensation fraud. Prosecution falls under the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office.
The reporting verified for this post does not state a company name, a DBPR license number, or a license status for Carballo, and no Construction Industry Licensing Board action has been reported. Do not add any of those to this case. The reports also list the charge names without stating the degree charged on each count. The ladders below are the grading rules the exam tests, not findings or charged degrees reported in this case.
02The workers comp fraud ladder: 440.105
Section 440.105(4)(b) makes it insurance fraud to, among other things:
- Knowingly make a false, fraudulent, or misleading statement, or knowingly omit or conceal material information required by Section 440.185 or 440.381, to obtain workers compensation coverage or to avoid, delay, or diminish premium payment. That is 440.105(4)(b)5.
- Knowingly misrepresent or conceal payroll, classification of workers, or loss history information material to the experience rating modification factor, to avoid or diminish premium payment. That is 440.105(4)(b)6. Concealing payroll through money service businesses, as alleged here, is the fact pattern this line describes.
- Fail to secure payment of workers compensation at all. That is a separate violation from holding a policy and concealing payroll on it. Carballo is alleged to have held a policy and underreported, not to have had no policy.
Section 440.105(4)(f) grades the offense by the amount of the claim or premium involved:
- Less than $20,000: third degree felony.
- $20,000 to less than $100,000: second degree felony.
- $100,000 or more: first degree felony.
The alleged premium loss here is $100,565.57. On the workers comp ladder, $100,000 is the first degree line, and the alleged figure clears it by $565.57. An exam question that rounds this to "about $100,000" and expects a degree is testing whether you compare the exact figure to the exact line.
03Do not mix the three ladders
The same arrest is reported to carry three charge names, and each has its own value ladder:
- Workers compensation fraud, 440.105(4)(f): $20,000 and $100,000 lines, graded on the premium or claim amount involved.
- Grand theft, 812.014: $750 floor, then $20,000 and $100,000 lines, graded on the value taken in each count.
- Organized fraud (scheme to defraud), 817.034(4)(a): $20,000 and $50,000 lines, graded on the aggregate value of property obtained. The first degree line here is $50,000, not $100,000.
A figure over $100,000 clears the top line on all three ladders, but the middle bands differ. Memorizing one ladder and applying it to every fraud charge is the error these questions are built to catch.
04The license track is separate
A criminal workers comp case does not decide the license case, and no board action has been reported here. The licensing rules the exam tests on this topic:
- Proof to get or keep the license: Section 489.115(5) makes proof of workers compensation compliance a condition of issuing or renewing a contractor license through the Construction Industry Licensing Board. Review the full list in Florida contractor license requirements.
- False insurance statements: Section 489.129(1)(k) makes signing a statement falsely indicating that workers compensation and public liability insurance are provided a ground for board discipline.
- $10,000 per violation: the maximum administrative fine under 489.129(1), in addition to reprimand, probation, suspension, revocation, and restitution.
- 1 employee: in the construction industry, workers compensation coverage is required once an employer has 1 or more employees. The general private employer threshold outside construction is 4. The classifications that count as construction are listed in Florida contractor license classifications.
05Testable numbers to memorize
- $968,278.71: payroll investigators say went unreported.
- $1,074,278.71: checks investigators say were cashed through money service businesses to conceal payroll.
- $9,297.43 paid, $100,565.57 lost: the premium Carballo paid for the policy year, and the premium loss investigators calculated.
- $20,000 / $100,000: the second degree and first degree lines for workers comp fraud under 440.105(4)(f). Under $20,000 is third degree.
- $50,000: the first degree line for organized fraud under 817.034(4)(a). Do not swap it with the $100,000 workers comp line.
- Nov. 5 and Nov. 10, 2026: arrest date, and the date DFS announced the arrest.
- Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office: the office DFS says will prosecute.
06Quiz yourself
Workers comp fraud bands, grand theft bands, and board discipline grounds are repeat Business and Finance topics. Test your recall with the free 12-question Florida practice test.
07Sources
- Florida Department of Financial Services, press release list, "Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia Announces Arrest After $100,000 Workers' Compensation Fraud Scheme," November 10, 2026 (MyFloridaCFO.com): https://myfloridacfo.com/news/pressreleases
- TJ McCormack, summary of the DFS November 10, 2026 announcement with the release's figures ($968,278.71 unreported payroll, $1,074,278.71 in checks cashed, $9,297.43 paid, $100,565.57 in lost premiums, November 5 arrest, Miami-Dade prosecution), LinkedIn, November 10, 2026: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/theworldsgreatestroofer_florida-workerscomp-construction-activity-7526138549591515136-DS_D
- Tampa Free Press coverage of the same arrest, "How A $9,000 Insurance Bill Ended With A Florida Contractor In Handcuffs," Jake Grissom, listed on Flipboard November 11, 2026 with the matching $9,297 premium figure: https://flipboard.com/@STATnews/states-sue-trump-administration-again-to-delay-medicaid-work-requirements/a-cAj_8dx5TOq48j8qs-U8fg%3Aa%3A3951212589-842044744e%2Fstatnews.com
- Florida Statutes Section 440.105, prohibited activities and the (4)(f) penalty ladder (Florida Senate): https://www.flsenate.gov/laws/statutes/2000/440.105
- Florida Standard Jury Instruction 20.29, Fraudulent Acts Pertaining to Workers Compensation Insurance, Section 440.105(4)(b), adopted June 27, 2025, restating the $20,000 and $100,000 bands: https://cfacdl.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/20.29.pdf
- Florida Statutes Section 817.034, Florida Communications Fraud Act, organized fraud ladder (Justia, 2025 Florida Statutes): https://law.justia.com/codes/florida/title-xlvi/chapter-817/part-i/section-817-034/
- Florida Statutes Section 489.129, disciplinary proceedings, including the (1)(k) false insurance statement ground and the $10,000 per violation fine cap (Online Sunshine): https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&Search_String=probation&URL=0400-0499/0489/Sections/0489.129.html